Clothing Company Strikes Up Controversy with Arabic Dearborn Shirt
A shirt made by the company Down with Detroit features a screenprint of "Dearborn" written in Arabic.
A T-shirt design released Wednesday by local clothing company Down with Detroit has stirred up conversation that the design is racist.
The design shows the word "Dearborn" written in Arabic.
Posted on the company's Facebook page Wednesday evening, the photo immediately sparked debate over whether the design is offensive.
"Maybe not racist ... maybe tasteless," wrote fan Dion Pallone. "Not a fan of it."
"Well, never bought a DWD shirt, and unless this ridiculous shirt is removed, I will never endorse it," added Jillian Christine.
"Dearborn is the largest Islamic area in the U.S.," contested fan Jeremy Welker. "If this is racist then so is having a brew on an Irish shirt, or having a rapper on a Detroit shirt."
As of Thursday morning, the post had more than 300 comments, 200 likes, and 32 shares.
Down with Detroit responded to many of the comments, but did not remove the shirt, contesting that it was no different than other shirts they had made about the heritage of some Michigan residents.
"This has nothing to do with politics," the company said. "Dearborn has the nation's largest Arab population. This design was made by an Iraqi-American who is Catholic."
Founded in 2006, Down with Detroit is a clothing company known for original designs that promote Detroit, surrounding suburbs and Michigan, as well as local sports teams. It has been named in HOUR Media's Best of Detroit.
The Dearborn shirt is not the only edgy design the company offers. One shirt displays "Taylortucky," a nickname given to the city of Taylor; another shirt for Mexicantown shows a cactus wearing a sombrero.
"To say it mildly, we were totally taken aback by the comments," the company posted Thursday morning. "We didn't view this design any differently than our Corktown, Hamtramck and Mexicantown shirts, but it sure was received differently!"
Access Down with Detroit online at http://downwithdetroit.spreadshirt.com.
Kristin
11:49 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
HOW IS THIS EDGY?? It says Dearborn in Arabic!!! Is anything in Arabic automatically edgy!? The comments on that picture are DISGUSTING and make me ashamed to read them.
Younes Sahli
3:08 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
GREAT POINT...
"ARABIC" WILL SOON BECOME THE ILLEGAL LANGUAGE...
PEOPLE NEED TO SHOW APPRECIATION FOR OTHER CULTURES...
JC
4:21 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Racist?! Sorry I dont see it.
Kathlyn Mooradian
11:58 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Who cares? Honestly this isn't a very tasteful story for the patch. If it was Italian or polish or armenian or Irish would you still be running this story? Probably not.
Kristin
11:58 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
What's not tasteful about it!?!? You make no sense!
Jessica Carreras
12:06 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
The story is about the controversy, not the shirt. Hundreds of people are talking about this on Facebook, so we thought it would be relevant to ask our readers' opinions. It in no way reflects my thoughts on the shirt.
Amena
12:27 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Im Arab-American and live in Dearborn and I love the idea of this T-shirt. I dont understand what makes it racist? I feel like its embracing the Arab Americans in Dearborn.
roger kantor
2:25 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
what is next are they going to remove the letter L in the english alphabet because it came the arabic letter _] and it pronounce the same.
Jerry Adams
2:38 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
It isn't racist - It is embracing Arab-Americans & It is Wonderful : )
dmonn
3:25 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
You are NOT Arab-American. If you were born here, you are American. If you were born say, in Jordan, you would be Jordanian. To be Arab refers to a group of people that have a similar language and customs. The only true "Arabs", if there is such a thing, would be those born on the Arabian Peninsula. The rest of the Arabic speaking population would be from some other country.
Bob
3:47 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
So DMonn by your 'thoughts" there isn't African americans, German Americans, Norwegian Americans, et.,al.? Who are you kidding, buddy, or is it bigotry that is raising it's ugly head here?
Pamela
4:25 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I'm not Arabic, live in Dearborn, and would be happy to wear the shirt. It celebrates an important part of the city!
Ian Kushnir
12:31 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Its the same as having a Hamtramick shirt in Polish
Dux-R-Us
3:51 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
dobre, dobre.
John Doh
12:39 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
i like it, does anyone know where i can get one?
JD
2:44 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
http://downwithdetroit.spreadshirt.com/shop/designs
Nathan Brown
1:16 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I don't understand how something written in another language is racists. Race has nothing to do with language. Some people need to get off their high horse and give their head a shake.
mooney
10:14 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I agree with you Nathan
M. Imsosure
12:41 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
I was trying to put words to my thoughts, you did it for me Nathan
Karen's
1:21 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Now if it was on a hoodie, THAT would easily be racist. Right?
(Stop taking the low road, Down with Detroit. Ignore those who are easily offended.)
Riles
2:51 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Aboslutely! LOL!
Scott Bloom
1:21 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
seems to be it would only be considered racist by people who ARE racist.
roger kantor
2:18 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
you are right i see t shirts has names of arab counrties on it in english, it is not big deal.so why is this big deal . then any shirts has arabic numerals is bad too.what about algebra, should they stop teaching algebra. some people are over sensitive for nothins
th
Riles
2:53 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I agree 100%!
Janet Vandenabeele
1:29 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
It seems like the people who are offended are *not* Arabic. I've been a fan of the company for some time and think their shirt designs are great, and this one is no exception. Non-Arab, non-Muslim Americans need to be exposed to more of this country's Arabic heritage and this is a fun way to do that.
jdc
1:32 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
great shirt, love that they support all of areas and their uniqueness's
jdc
1:33 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Should have read "all areas" Its the PC crowd and the s*** stirrers trying to make noise. I hope it sells more shirts for DWD.
Beth
1:36 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
John, Google Down With Detroit and you'll find their site.
I am from Michigan and live the company DWD, they have made some great shirts. I like this design a lot. It is a big part of Michigan's heritage and is very important to the area.
Saji Thabolingam
1:42 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
while i personally dont like the shirt (as i dont speak arabic), i find it sad that ppl are up in arms about it. we have all seen shirts in different languages. speaking to those that are upset, would u be mad if it was in spanish, hindi, portugese, french... whatever?
shadia
1:43 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
As an ALL-AMERICAN Muslim, I WILL HAPPILY ENDORSE THIS SHIRT! People need to stop being so RACIST and GROW UP already. Always afraid of NOTHING! Very cute shirt idea.
Amena
10:41 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Shadia? From All-American Muslim?
Aiman
2:28 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I support english, French, Italian , Hindu, Chinese, but definitely not Arabic, because....you know why?? I do not know why, but the media encourage me to hate the arabs at every moment and every turn., So I suport the media. am I brian washed??? oh, no I am just a media puppet.
Farouk Hegazi
2:58 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
First of all, you probably know that your name is a wide spread Arabic Muslim name. I understand your feeling since I grew-up hating Jews because that is how I grew-up. I got over it and you hopefully will get over it one day. By the way, your name means believing in god (in Arabic)
Pamela
4:28 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I assume you are joking...
jina mardo
4:44 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
You need to wake up sweetheart . Who is media ? media are us you and me and everybody else . try to be fair
Jerry Adams
2:41 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I am a what? American-American? and I would wear the shirt - people can be such idiots
Younes Sahli
3:05 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
HOW IS THAT RACIST...
IT IS SIMPLY WRITING AN ENGLISH WORD IN ANOTHER LANGUAGE...
Barbara Paul
3:08 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I find it more offensive that this company is all about saying it supports Detroit , yet when you order from them their T-Shirts come from Hebron Kentucky. Now I understand that the clothing is made overseas, but hire a local silkscreening company! If they are Down with Detroit, keep the work in Detroit or at least Michigan !
Alexander Milian
3:18 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
How can it be racist?Muslim is not a race and the majority of all such people are caucasian aka white
Jerrest Green
3:19 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Americans come on NOW. Do everything has to be about race?
Bob
3:22 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Racist? Cut me a break! Bigoted? Don't think that either. Grow up and stop the political correctness that is so pervasive in our sick society.
William Dann
3:56 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
What am I missing? I've seen shirts with different cities names on them in several languages.
ousmane
3:57 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
westing time writing has nothing to do with the race, just get a job!
p
4:05 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
im sorry, yet i think that some people are a bit too sensitive about certian things...
Lebsun
4:14 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
It is so sad that it is the year 2012 and ignorant comments such as terrorist & go back to your country are still being said . This is a country of " immigrants " , people need to read U.S. History , just like it was acceptable for the Greeks, Mexicans , and Polish it should be acceptable for the Arab - American community !
POWDERBURNER
8:55 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
When my grandparents immigrated here from Poland in 1904 they went to work, not on welfare.
Joy Maulvi
4:22 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I am shaking my head here. It is a shirt that says Dearborn on it! Blows my mind how people can see this offensive!??!! .. I would like one that says Missoula where I live. I think it is awesome!
Capt
4:45 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
This is crazy! I have way more offensive shirts hanging up in my closet. Yeah, I get people that turn there nose up, but I get alot more laughs. Racism will never die, not in my life time. Only time I have witness a calming was after 9/11, when were nothing but Americans. Except for brown people, every ignorant person thought there neighbor who was brown was a terrorist. One of my best friends is Lebanese, you wouldnt believe what he went threw and hes a Christian!
Common Sense
4:57 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Offended= Ignorant? One can't tell the difference here !!!!!
Sonya
5:06 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
I don't love the shirt, but only because it's not very attractive, not because I think it's edgy or racist. The written Arabic language is very beautiful and a similar shirt can be made with a much nicer design. That being said, The University of Michigan has been printing shirts in dozens of languages for years, including Arabic. Is it offensive only because it says "Dearborn" in Arabic? Also, it seems that those who are offended are not Arabs who think this is racist, but rather non-Arabs offended by a shirt that has Arabic writing on it, which as an Arab American I do find offensive. Also, some of the information quoted from the DWD and a local commenter about Dearborn having the highest Islamic population or the highest Arab population in the country are incorrect, statistically speaking. However, I will say good job Dearborn Patch for sharing this story.
Jessica Carreras
6:48 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
You are very correct, Sonya - I think it's a common misconception that Dearborn has the biggest Arab population in the country. I believe that title actually goes to New York City. However, Dearborn does have the largest concentration of Arab residents in the country, last time I checked.
Jahna B.
12:55 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
This is from an article written in 2003 - so almost a decade ago. I'm having trouble getting current numbers.. but this is what it brown the numbers, then, down to: " Almost half of the Arabs in the United States live in five states -- California (190,890), New York (120,370), Michigan (115,284), New Jersey (71,770) and Florida (77,461)." - NewsMax.com Wires Thursday, Dec. 4, 2003
http://archive.newsmax.com/archives/articles/2003/12/3/192906.shtml
Jahna B.
12:58 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
addendum: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_American (Though I know Wiki isn't always the greatest source)... . "According to the 2010 U.S. Census, the city with the largest percentage of Arab Americans is Dearborn, Michigan, a southwestern suburb of Detroit, at nearly 40%. The Detroit metropolitan area is home to the largest concentration of Arab Americans (403,445), followed by the New York City Combined Statistical Area (371,233), Los Angeles (308,295), Chicago (176,208), and Washington D.C. (168,208).[2] (NOTE: This information is reportedly based upon survey findings, but is contradicted by information posted on the Arab American Institute website itself, which states that California as a whole only has 272,485, and Michigan as a whole only 191,607. 2010 American Community Survey information from the American Factfinder website gives a figure of about 168,000 for Michigan.)"
Joey D
10:00 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Does anyone know how to order these in bulk?
Jahna B.
12:46 pm on Friday, March 30, 2012
I wouldn't wear it simply because I am not Arabic and cannot read it..But it's not racist! I do own shirts that display disabled people in wheelchairs as I am in one, I also am in the process of ordering bumper stickers that comment on my short stature. How is any of that different? People need to lighten up. There are more things in this world to worry over than a tee shirt!
Abu Ali
7:54 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
I'm Arab American and about to order me one. Love it.
Rita Dennaoui
9:54 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
I am an Arab American, and I would not wear it. Not because it is offensive rather I find it ugly. As for Dearborn having the highest Arabic people well that is very incorrect. I find it so sad, that we always have to associate Dearborn with Arabs, when this city was founded and built originally by the Italian , Polish, and the Irish. Maybe, Dearborn needs to stand as Dearborn and not as being Arab. Guess what, I find nothing beautiful about the shirt, and nor will I buy one. Lets not forget there are other people who live in this city, and there those who have been pushed away of the focus we have given to one race. Get a grip on this crap.
Dan Merritt
11:29 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
The only thing distasteful about this shirt is that I can only find it printed on a Raglan cut (aka Jersey cut), that style shirt went out in the 80's with feathered hair cuts and bell bottoms.
Otherwise I would be proud to wear one.
Lee Jacobsen
1:08 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Most clothing such as T shirts are produced overseas due to cost factors. However, the screen printing, or digital printing, is done usually in the USA, making it a 'made in USA' product.
Would the term 'Middle East' work as a melting pot term for some folk from the Dearborn area?
Europeans are French , German, etc, so perhaps Middle East folk are from Iraq, Jordan, Israel, Lebanon, etc.
We are all Americans first, of course! I need a T shirt that says 'Dearborn' in Norwegian. Most folk don't realize that Dearborn has the 153rd highest concentration of folk from Norway right here in their back yard! Long live 'Sons of Norway!'
Carla O'Neill
3:21 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
What I find distasteful is the misleading name of "Down With Detroit." For awhile, I did not visit the website, believing it was a site condemning the Detroit area. I wonder how many other people were fooled by the name.
POWDERBURNER
9:07 pm on Saturday, March 31, 2012
I have a t-shirt with INFIDEL printed in both arabic gobbledegook and English on it. It gets a lot of looks when I wear it around town, mostly looks that could kill. So much for freedom of expression, it obviously isn't a 2 way street with them.
AC
2:41 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
FYI, in the middle east, no one uses this term 'infidel.' It is a western construct projected on to to Arabs.
Bob
3:49 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
Ac, you need to read the quaran.
Leslie
8:50 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
It's just the word Dearborn written in Arabic! Amazing how much conversation and controversy it's generated! It would be fun to have a shirt with Dearborn written in the many languages of the people that have lived in Dearborn over the years (including Norwegian). Like the old AAA stickers that said "Bring 'em back alive!" in many languages -- we collected them as kids.
Julia
5:04 pm on Saturday, April 21, 2012
In an effort to defend this shirt, I think it is a good idea for Down With Detroit to highlight the fact that their intention was not to offend people. It would be different if the text on the shirt said something negative about Dearborn or Arabs, but it does not. Having one word, the name of a city, in a different translation than English is nothing compared to real issues of racism. The bigger, more substantiated racial threats deserve the energy and attention rather than the way a city name is written. The company has produced items with very similar images on them in the past, and yet those items did not have this kind of controversy surrounding them. Obviously if those other products continued to sell and did not lose consumers, it is understandable that the company would see this shirt as not being a big deal as well. Down With Detroit hasn't shown any signs of cultural, religious, or racial hatred in its existence and so it is important for the public to view this product in relation to the entire image of the company rather than a single representation of racism. Down With Detroit should display the facts to the public, regarding both the company's intentions and history, so that people can put this individual shirt in context with the many other products this company offers.